Andy Jeremiah
Andy Jeremiah co-founded Mr Game Show Florida with Tracey Geremia in 2021. The pair built the brand to host game nights for planned communities across the region. It was later featured on the How I Built This podcast.
Andy Jeremiah's Bio
Andy Jeremiah co-founded Mr Game Show Florida with Tracey Geremia, turning their own community game nights in Venice, Florida, into a full-time live-events business. The company hosts game show-style experiences for retirement communities, planned neighborhoods, and corporate groups across Sarasota and Fort Myers, blending interactive entertainment with local connection.
Their grassroots growth caught the attention of the How I Built This team, leading to an Advice Line appearance where Andy sought guidance on scaling personality-driven entertainment beyond Southwest Florida. The founders' challenge was packaging their charisma and on-stage chemistry into something another host could deliver, since the duo themselves had become the product.
Jeremiah's background before Mr Game Show Florida included community organizing and event planning, giving him the operational foundation to turn a popular hobby into a repeatable business model. His Advice Line conversation focused on whether to license the format, build an app, or create a certification program that could teach other hosts to run Mr Game Show events.
Career Timeline
2019 — Started hosting community game nights
Began organizing local game show events in Venice, Florida, testing formats that would later become the Mr Game Show Florida experience.
2021 — Officially launched Mr Game Show Florida
Co-founded the formal business with Tracey Geremia, expanding from casual community nights to structured events for planned communities and organizations.
2023 — Featured on How I Built This Advice Line
Appeared on the podcast to ask Guy Raz and Curt Richardson how to scale the Mr Game Show concept outside the local Florida market.